FDNY EMS Pension vs. Fire Pension:
The Gap Nobody Talks About

Back to Articles

Two Pension Systems, One Department

FDNY is one department, but its members are covered by two entirely different pension systems. Firefighters belong to the FDNY Pension Fund (Article 1-B). EMS workers, meaning EMTs and paramedics, belong to NYCERS (New York City Employees' Retirement System).

This isn't just an administrative distinction. It creates a fundamentally different retirement outcome for people doing equally dangerous work.

What Changed for EMS in 2025 and 2026

Several laws signed in the last two years reach FDNY EMS directly. Here they are, as of October 8, 2026.

• Lower Tier 6 contributions from October 1, 2026. Chapter 58 of 2026, Part XX, cut the basic Tier 6 contribution rate for NYCERS members: 3% of pay up to $75,000, 4% from $75,001 to $100,000, 5.25% from $100,001 to $125,000, and 5.75% above that. EMTs in the 25-year plan also pay an additional contribution for the plan, so ask NYCERS how your own total changes.
• A cap on pensionable overtime from January 1, 2027. The same law set the Tier 6 overtime ceiling at $30,000 a year for 2027, rising 3% a year after that. Overtime above the ceiling does not count toward your pension.
• A three-year final average salary. Since April 20, 2024 (Chapter 56 of 2024, Part QQ), a Tier 6 pension is figured on your best three consecutive years, not five.
• The World Trade Center death window is now 35 years. Chapter 295 of 2026, signed September 10, 2026, covers NYCERS members, EMS included. If a retiree who worked the WTC rescue, recovery or clean-up dies of a qualifying WTC condition within 35 years of retiring (it was 25), the family can apply to have it treated as a line-of-duty death and receive the accidental death benefit.
• The WTC Notice deadline is September 11, 2030. Chapter 296 of 2026 moved it from 2026. Filing the Notice of Participation with NYCERS is what keeps the WTC presumptions open to you later.
• Higher line-of-duty survivor benefits. Chapter 151 of 2025 and Chapter 157 of 2026 each raised the Special Accidental Death Benefit paid to the families of members, EMTs among them, who died in the line of duty.

The Gap in Numbers

Why the Gap Exists

1. Different pension funds with different rules

The FDNY Pension Fund was designed specifically for uniformed firefighters, with a generous 50%-after-20-years formula. EMTs and paramedics are in NYCERS, on its EMT 25-year plan: a flat 50% of final average salary at 25 years of service, at any age, plus 2% of final average salary a year for years 26 to 30. The same 50%, five years later.

2. Lower base salaries

An FDNY EMT's starting base salary is about $44,000. A firefighter starts at roughly $54,000. By career end, firefighters typically earn $105K-$120K with overtime, while senior paramedics reach the high-$80Ks to low-$90Ks in base pay, more with overtime. Since pensions are calculated on final average salary, the gap compounds.

3. No Variable Supplements Fund (VSF)

Firefighters receive an additional payment from the Variable Supplements Fund, a fixed $12,000 per year on top of their pension. EMS workers in NYCERS receive no equivalent supplement.

"Same department. Same dangers. Same city. But the EMS worker retires with roughly a third less annual income than the firefighter standing next to them at the scene. That gap doesn't close on its own."

4 Strategies to Close the Gap

1 Max the NYC Deferred Comp 457(b)

The NYC Deferred Compensation Plan (457(b)) is the single most powerful tool EMS workers have. In 2026, you can contribute up to $24,500 (or $32,500 if 50+). Unlike a 401(k), there's no 10% early withdrawal penalty on 457(b) plans after separation from service, regardless of age.

If an EMT contributes $15,000/year for 25 years at a 7% return, that's roughly $950,000 at retirement. That's the gap-closer.

2 Roth vs. Traditional: Get It Right

For EMS workers in lower tax brackets early in their careers, Roth 457(b) contributions are worth weighing. You pay tax now at 12-22%, and every dollar of growth is tax-free forever. At retirement, combining a NYCERS pension (taxable) with Roth 457(b) withdrawals (tax-free) creates a powerful tax-diversified income stream.

3 Know How Overtime Counts in Your Final Years

The EMT 25-year plan pays a flat 50% of your Final Average Salary (FAS) at 25 years, and FAS is your best three consecutive years. So each $1,000 added to FAS adds about $500 a year to a 25-year pension. Two limits apply. Any one year that runs more than 10% above the years before it is cut back. And for Tier 6 members, overtime above the yearly ceiling ($30,000 in 2027, rising 3% a year) does not count at all. Overtime in your last years still matters, but less than it used to for anyone working a lot of it.

4 Coordinate With 9/11-Related Benefits

Many FDNY EMS workers are also eligible for VCF awards and USVSST distributions for 9/11-related health conditions. A VCF award for a physical condition is federally tax-free (IRS Pub 3920). A USVSST distribution is not automatically tax-free: whether it is taxable depends on the character of the award, so confirm the treatment with your tax professional. Either way, these funds can supplement your pension income, and how they are invested affects your taxes (see our VCF investment strategy guide).

The 25-Year Model: What's Possible

The gap doesn't close automatically. But with disciplined 457(b) contributions and tax-efficient planning, an FDNY EMS worker can retire with income that matches or exceeds a firefighter's pension.

What Should You Do Now?

1. Check your NYCERS tier. Tier 4 and Tier 6 have different rules and multipliers
2. Log into NYC Deferred Comp and verify your contribution amount and Roth/Traditional split
3. Calculate your FAS. How much could overtime in your final 3 years increase your lifetime pension?
4. Map your full benefit picture: pension + 457(b) + VCF/USVSST + Social Security

Sources

The primary sources behind this article, so you can read them yourself:

• NYC Fire Pension Fund, the Fund's own site. For firefighters and fire officers, only the Fund can confirm your service credit, tier and benefit.
• NYCERS EMT-25 Plan (Brochure #936)
• NYC Admin Code §§13-383 and 13-385 (Firefighters' Variable Supplements Fund)
• IRS Publication 3920 (9/11 VCF tax treatment)
• NYCERS 2026 laws (Chapter 58 Part XX, Chapters 157, 295, 296)
• NYCERS 2025 laws (Chapter 151)
• Chapter 295 of 2026 (S10085)
• S4598, vetoed 2025
• S9378 (2026, not signed)
• S7916-A (committee)

Working with us: Sirmium Capital works with FDNY members and retirees. What we do, how the firm is paid and how to start.